Crawling Kobold

currently in the sweet embrace of his pack

Non-Arbitrary Encounters

The Dungeon Master’s Guide for Dungeons & Dragons 5.5 introduces random encounters in Chapter 4, page 119. A direct definition or breakdown isn’t given, and instead the gameplay experience it brings to the table is highlighted in these six bullet-points:

  • Create Urgency: Pushing the adventuring party forward without planning encounters, keeping up the pace.
  • Drain Character Resources: Expanding Hit Points and spell slots to render them vulnerable and increase tension.
  • Establish Atmosphere: Introducing tone and colour through a curated roster of enemies.
  • Providing Assistance: Sometimes they aren’t hostile but instead helpful to the party.
  • Reinforcing Campaign Themes: Reminding players of the themes and conflicts of the adventure.
  • A Life of Its Own: Random encounters can prompt impromptu adventures that can become important and meaningful.

And that’s… it? No other mentioning of random encounters before or after? The third and the fifth points are pretty much identical, so we are practically down to five points. At least give me an example table… I mean, there is 350 pages in this book, yet random encounters are given only half a page of exposure. This would make one believe they aren’t important to a game. Yet, chapters 3 and 4 of Lost Mine of Phandelver (the starter set and first ever adventure module of 5e) use wilderness and dungeon random encounters, respectively. Good, then they must be the example of play with random encounters(!)

Example of Play According to Wizards of the Coast

Let’s open them up and see what’s inside: Filler combat, filler combat, more filler combat… oh I think I got something. “Goblins know where their castle is.” You mean the castle I’m trying to find by exploring the main encounters with battlemaps, dungeons, and cool loot? As in, I can skip the cool stuff by fighting 1d6+3 Goblins on a nameless road?

I did not survive my first contact with random encounter tables… They were random and they were encounters, so they delivered on that front at least. But I did not feel the presence of the previously mentioned elements. Instead of pushing the narrative with randomness, they only felt arbitrary. Who cares if I fight these Stirges? “But you get XP.” But I didn’t do anything for it? They came to me, I killed them, and got XP for it. I made no meaningful decisions in this process. Also, the Stirges drop pennies worth of XP compared to actually progressing the main plot (as it should be.) After this less-than-great first impression with random encounter tables, I grew cold, and cut them out of my next adventure, which I thought was a great idea (oh the naiveté of youth.) More about that in the future.

So, how are we supposed to use random encounter tables in the big 26? Surely, we need the adventure to be fit to accommodate the random tables. If we are running a narrative-heavy adventure that leans more on the linear side of things, random encounters will not help us. We need our plot points to be pre-arranged and presented correctly, at the right narrative beats. Instead, the adventure must be designed from the beginning to serve the narrative through the random encounters.

Introducing Direction Into Randomness

But how can we serve a story through just 2d10 Stirges, 1d10 Goblins, 1d4 Ogres + 1d6 Bugbears, etc.? By levelling up our tables to serve more than just enemies. I swear, the twenty pages of useless tables in Xanathar’s Guide to Everything reinforces only the wrong things about using random encounters. We don’t care about what we are fighting. What we really care about is: “OK, we defeated them, now what?” What is tension, if there is no resolution? Justin Alexander addresses this very well in his So You Want to be a Game Master, through rumour tables: We do not stop with only making an enemy table, but a complimentary rumour table that contains information about the adventure.

In the newest Dark Sun/Mad Max inspired mystery/survival point-crawl I put together, I wanted to communicate how miserable and deadly this region is, which I decided to enforce through hostile enemy factions and heavily mutated wildlife that are constantly breathing down the PCs’ necks. However, this can quickly turn into a game of only gritty survival and crawling. To reward my players with more than just the fact that they didn’t perish but also new information about the world they are in so that they can make meaningful decisions following this encounter, I also roll on my rumour table simultaneously. We can even add a third loot table to the mix. Combining multiple of these tables is a great way to prompt a seed for the random encounter. For example, if I roll for a Dead Skinz patrol encounter with the rumour the Blood Dogs are running out of water in their western outpost and the loot brand new binoculars, this helps greatly with regards to how to make this specific patrol encounter different than all the others. Perhaps they are on their way to raid the Blood Dogs outpost, or they are returning to get a larger raiding party? Perhaps they are only on a scouting mission, thus the binoculars? All of a sudden, this feels like a curated encounter, even though it was completely random. But what it isn’t is: arbitrary. After facing the encounter, the players now have access to information and items that they can leverage to make—one last time, with gusto this time—meaningful decisions. This only works because I didn’t put a random encounter table to put “content” (or lack thereof) and instead built the whole adventure around facilitating these rumours. The encounters are purely a vessel for me to communicate with my players the treasures and dangers of the world.

2 responses

  1. Dan avatar

    I love the idea of combining rumours with random encounters; their arbitrariness has always bothered me, too. I’ve played around with populating random encounters based on previous campaign events (eg, those gnolls whose treasure you swiped have been tracking you and just caught up), but this feels much more natural and organic. Good stuff!

    1. Umut Ucak avatar
      Umut Ucak

      Past events would be great at restocking these tables (if the need ever rises). I really like that idea too! I usually implement such encounters directly in my session prep, but no reason why they couldn’t exist in a random encounter or rumour table. Thanks for reading and leaving a comment.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *